The 5 Best Jewellery Stores in Toronto

The 7 Best Jewellery Stores in Toronto

Is an engagement coming up soon or do you just want to treat yourself to the finest pieces of jewellery?

Whatever your purpose for jewellery hunting is, we have the answers for you!

In this review, we selected the best jewellery stores in Toronto based on things like the variety of pieces they offer, reputation, customer service, and policies. Read on for a more in-depth dive into these factors.

The Cost of Jewellery in Toronto

Okay, here’s the thing – the cost of jewellery is highly variable. But we’ll do our best to give you a solid idea of what you’ll pay for it in the city.

The average cost per unit in jewellery stores is $1,000. But the price can go up depending on the following factors:

  • Design of the piece
  • Craftsmanship
  • Materials and stones used
  • Alterations or modifications
  • Rarity of the piece
  • Condition of the piece

On a scale, jewellery starts at $40 and goes up to $10,000. For engagement rings, the average is $3,500 in Canada.

Top Jewellery Shops in Toronto

Here are the criteria we used to select and rate these:

Variety of jewellery pieces including earrings, rings, necklaces, charms, bracelets, and other jewellery-related items. Preferably a collection with complementary designs (e.g. rings + bracelet + necklace) available.
Reputation and credibility that we assessed based on customer satisfaction after reaching out to each shop’s past clients. We also looked into community recommendations and evaluated clients who were referred to the shop.
Customer service from how helpful and knowledgeable the staff is to the general shopping experience. After-care services such as repairs, alterations, polishing, etc. were also considered.
Guarantees and policies such as insurance, shipping policies, and return policies. A policy is considered favorable if it meets the customer’s needs without compromising the shop’s sale terms.

1. Made You Look

Made You Look's Homepage
TestInfo
SERVICESWedding & engagement pieces, custom designs, services & repairs
WEBSITEhttps://www.madeyoulook.ca/
ADDRESS1338 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6K 1L4,
CONTACT DETAILS+1 416-463-2136
OPERATING HOURSMonday - Friday: 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Saturday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Sunday: 12:00 PM - 5:00 PM

Total Scores

Variety of jewellery pieces★★★★★ (5/5)
Reputation and credibility★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Customer satisfaction★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Community recommendation★★★★☆ (4/5)
Customer service★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Staff★★★☆☆ (3/5)
⮕Shopping experience★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕After-care services★★★★★ (5/5)
Guarantees and policies★★★★★ (5/5)

Made You Look is the ideal benchmark for all jewellery stores and the experience they bring. Let’s take a look at what this shop does best in jewellery service.

Starting off with variety, the selection in this shop is immense. From bangles to engagement rings, necklaces to earrings – they basically have it all.

Of course, in a jewellery shop, this is something you’d naturally expect. But what sets them apart is that they make unique pieces, making the designs exclusively yours.

The jewellery pieces they put out aren’t mass-produced. Plus, each and every piece is locally created by over 100 Canadian designers, turning the jewellery into wearable art.

We also liked that they offer custom designs where they upgrade existing jewellery. Thankfully, they have an in-house designer whom clients can commission to personalize the item for them.

So far so good – the shopping experience for us was good at their store, even for casual browsing. Pieces are displayed well and staff were extremely helpful at all times.

However, this is where we also started finding complaints from others who’ve gone to them. Some of the clients we’ve reached out to raised concerns about staff treatment that killed the experience for them.

We don’t take these concerns lightly so we looked further into these matters. Fortunately, the positive experiences far outweighed the negative ones, so we’ll take that with a grain of salt for now.

In terms of after-care services, we find them favorable and fair for both the shop and customer. For instance, if you need repairs due to a material defect, they’ll fix it for you for free.

Other repairs are already subject to certain charges depending on the nature of service. Overall, the costs don’t exceed the expensive mark on our meter, earning a thumbs up from us.

Pros

  • Locally-made jewellery pieces
  • Items made by local Canadian designers
  • Custom designs available
  • Favorable after-care services and repairs
  • Specialize in engagement rings
  • Uses 100% recycled metal, materials, and certified stones

Cons

  • Minor issues with staff and customer service

Customer Reviews

Honest and passionate

This store has a beautiful collection of unique, hand made jewellery. The atmosphere is welcoming and staff are super friendly and helpful. Been a few times over the years and recently went in to get a quote for a custom piece from a designer who was available on site. They are honest, informative and passionate about their work. I can’t say enough good things about this place. Will go out of my way for my next visit! – Scarlett Yan

Exceptional care

Very professional and welcoming. Had an heirloom ring resized and they took exceptional care. Ellen the goldsmith was honest and accommodated my requests while also making great suggestions on the direction to go for the rework. Big thanks to Aminda as well for the excellent communication. Would highly recommend to anyone. – Dan Losier

2. Anne Sportun Jewellery

Anne Sportun Jewellery's Homepage
TestInfo
SERVICESBracelets, charms, earrings, necklaces, rings
WEBSITEhttps://www.annesportun.com/
ADDRESS742 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1E9
CONTACT DETAILS+1 416-363-4114 | [email protected]
OPERATING HOURSTuesday - Friday: 11:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Saturday: 11:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Total Scores

Variety of jewellery pieces★★★★☆ (4/5)
Reputation and credibility★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Customer satisfaction★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Community recommendation★★★★☆ (4/5)
Customer service★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Staff★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Shopping experience★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕After-care services★★★☆☆ (3/5)
Guarantees and policies★★★★☆ (4/5)

Anne Sportun is our top choice when it comes to unique, handmade jewellery.

In terms of selection, you get a variety of pieces here. You can score charms, bracelets, necklaces, rings, and the like.

However, their in-stock pieces are actually pretty limited in number. But there are good reasons behind it that justify this issue. 

For starters, the pieces are handmade by Anne Sportun herself as well as other select designers. There isn’t a lot in stock because all the pieces are unique and one-of-a-kind.

Second, the shop is more inclined towards personalized pieces. In fact, in our opinion, their personalized design service is the best among their offerings because of how smooth the process is.

To give you an idea, many clients praised Anne for her talent and care. There’s always regular contact throughout the process and none even complained about the product they got.

Even the shopping experience mirrors this level of customer service. The staff aren’t only helpful but are clearly knowledgeable about the pieces they sell.

On the flip side, this isn’t the kind of store where you can casually drop by. You need an appointment to purchase on-site or book for a virtual shopping experience.

To be fair, this is a high-end boutique so the experience really screams exclusivity. Plus, clients have an option to shop online or pick up their online orders at the shop.

The only thing we want to see more of is after-purchase services like repairs. So far, the shop is lacking in that area so we’d love to see it in the future.

Pros

  • Unique handmade pieces
  • Goldsmith and designer with 35 years of experience
  • Features pieces from select designers
  • Releases special jewellery collections
  • Great process for customized engagement rings
  • Online shopping and pickup options available

Cons

  • Requires appointment for in-store and virtual shopping
  • Lacks after-care services and related repairs
  • Little in-stock inventory

Customer Reviews

Second to none experience

My fiancé and I had a brilliant experience working with Anne to design our engagement ring. Her knowledge is second to none and she kept in regular contact with us throughout the whole process of designing the ring; from sourcing the stones to creating the setting. Definitely recommend for any custom jewellery! – Amelie

Friendly, welcoming, and knowledgeable

Unbelievable service. 100% would recommend going here if you’re anxious about purchasing an engagement ring. Such friendly, welcoming and knowledgeable staff; there’s no doubt we’ll be going there again to buy the wedding bands. I can’t thank them enough for such amazing service and creating such beautiful jewellery. – Joe Kemple

3. Kimberfire

Kimberfire's Homepage
TestInfo
SERVICESCustom made jewellery
WEBSITEhttps://www.kimberfire.com/
ADDRESS27 Queen St E #1204, Toronto, ON M5C 2M6,
CONTACT DETAILS+1 416-861-8110
OPERATING HOURSMonday - Friday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Total Scores

Variety of jewellery pieces★★★★☆ (4/5)
Reputation and credibility★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Customer satisfaction★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Community recommendation★★★★★ (5/5)
Customer service★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Staff★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Shopping experience★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕After-care services★★★☆☆ (3/5)
Guarantees and policies★★★★☆ (4/5)

If you want the ultimate personalized experience, Kimberfire is our top recommendation. Let’s list down the reasons they’re among the best in the industry.

First, the buying experience is tailor-fit to the client’s taste. Everything here is customized to meet the demands of the customer through a consultant.

Speaking of a consultant, the shop has a team of diamond and jewellery experts. Clients can connect with them on-site or online for free.

Second, no two of their diamonds are alike – every piece is unique and ethically sourced. To give you peace of mind, they also have certificates from grading laboratories around the world.

Third, the level of customer service that you get here is second to none. And their perfect 5-star rating on Google Reviews reflects this best.

In line with this, both the online and on-site shopping experience is wonderful. There’s no upselling or pressure to buy, plus the consultants always keep clients in the loop.

Finally, they have a great variety of jewellery pieces at very competitive price points. Although they specialize in engagement rings, they also sell necklaces, pendants, and bracelets.

Now, with all these amazing things listed above, we did find a couple of things that we wish will improve.

We would prefer to see a more comprehensive after-care service. They concentrate mostly on diamonds so matters like that will be highly appreciated.

In addition, we actually think that a few couple in-stock items will also be helpful, just to better visualize potential designs. Still, customized pieces are their forte so we’ll let that pass, for now.

Pros

  • Specializes in custom made jewellery
  • Diamond and jewellery consultants available on-site or online
  • Free consultations
  • Has certificates from grading laboratories
  • Competitive prices for high-end pieces
  • Free shipping in Canada
  • Direct access to wholesale diamonds

Cons

  • Lacks in after-care services
  • No in-stock items to check out

Customer Reviews

Top-notch experience

Did quite a bit of research before buying this eternity ring for my wife. I ended going with Kimberfire, which was a very good decision. Jeehea helped me with the design and even got the ring made in time for my anniversary.  Pricing was better than those of the usual suspects. In the end, the wife loves the ring, which is the most important thing!! – Felix Wong

Exceptional service

Kimberfire offers high quality and exceptional service! We reached out during COVID when stores were still mainly closed and Larissa was still able to provide great service via online meetings to discuss our needs and preferences. Overall process was very easy and Larissa was always available for any questions. We loved the final ring! – Brandon Ing

4. Fair Trade Jewellery Co.

Fair Trade Jewellery Co.'s Homepage
TestInfo
SERVICESCustom and ready-to-wear rings and bands
WEBSITEhttps://ftjco.com/
ADDRESS576 Parliament St, Toronto, ON M4X 1P8
CONTACT DETAILS+1 647-430-8741
OPERATING HOURSTuesday - Sunday: 11:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Total Scores

Variety of jewellery pieces★★★☆☆ (3/5)
Reputation and credibility★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Customer satisfaction★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Community recommendation★★★★☆ (4/5)
Customer service★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Staff★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Shopping experience★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕After-care services★★★★★ (5/5)
Guarantees and policies★★★★★ (5/5)

Fair Trade Jewellery Co. is leading the game when it comes to uniqueness and materials. Let’s get to know them more to know if they’re worth your money.

To start off, if you’re looking for a variety of pieces, you may be disappointed. They only sell rings here but they do it best, in our opinion.

Whatever they lack in other jewellery pieces, they make up for a variety in styles and stones. You can buy rings with fine-cut diamonds or a collection of precious stones depending on your taste.

Additionally, these orders come in various formats. They can be ready-to-wear, made-to-order, custom-made, and upgraded from your existing item.

We also appreciate that they sell pre-loved items that are usually cheaper than retail. Plus, they offer financing options that make paying so much easier in the pocket.

Another thing worth noting in this shop is their complete client care. All their terms in insurance, repairs, returns, and more are solid for all customers.

For starters, clients get a lifetime warranty to replace and repair any workmanship defects. They also enjoy a free one-year, all-perils insurance policy from Jewelers Mutual.

Resizing is also free within the first year of purchase as well as its two-way shipping in Canada. Returns and repurchases are subject to certain terms as defined by the store.

To wrap it up, the customer service is as incredible as the quality of the products. We only found a minor complaint on hidden fees, but so far, we’re pretty happy with what we’ve seen.

Pros

  • Accredited to carry SCS-007 sustainability rated diamonds
  • Ready-to-wear and custom pieces available
  • Lifetime warranty to workmanship defects
  • Free one-year, all-perils insurance policy
  • Free two-way shipping in Canada
  • Comprehensive client care services

Cons

  • Minor issues on hidden fees

Customer Reviews

Incredible level of service

My husband and I had both of our rings custom made by these incredibly talented and delightful people! Getting custom made rings during a pandemic was not the hassle I thought it would be, even from Ottawa. I’m not an off the rack kind of person and it was so easy to sort out the most perfect ring for me. None of you dare copy it!! Have these magicians create something for you, that feels like you! – Rae Jackson

Easy and smooth process

My partner and I both had our engagement rings custom made by Ftjco and we are delighted with them. The whole process was so easy and smooth and we never felt any pressure. We also really love that everything is ethically done . They took special care to make our visions a reality and we could not be happier with the finished products. We will be back for our wedding bands! – Roisin Gaffney

5. Anice Jewellery

Anice Jewellery's Homepage
TestInfo
SERVICESReady-made and custom pieces, wedding & engagement, workshops, rework on vintage jewellery
WEBSITEhttps://www.anicejewellery.com/
ADDRESS102 Ossington Ave, Toronto, ON M6J 2Z4
CONTACT DETAILS+1 647-351-5526
OPERATING HOURSThursday - Saturday: 12:00 PM - 6:00 PM

Sunday 12:00 PM - 5:00 PM

Total Scores

Variety of jewellery pieces★★★★★ (5/5)
Reputation and credibility★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Customer satisfaction★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Community recommendation★★★★☆ (4/5)
Customer service★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Staff★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Shopping experience★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕After-care services★★★★☆ (4/5)
Guarantees and policies★★★☆☆ (3/5)

Anice Jewellery is the perfect place to go if you want to treat yourself to something unique and vintage. Here are more reasons why it should be one of your top options.

For starters, you can buy loads of items here such as rings, necklaces, and more. They also even sell anklets and nose rings, which most shops don’t have. 

The real star of this shop is their reworking services. If you have vintage jewellery, they can do the magic to make it look brand new again.

In this process, you’ll be in the hands of your in-house experts for consultation. This 30-minute session is free, which we definitely appreciate.

Another thing that they do very well in is their custom on-the-spot service available on-site and online. Customers can simply drop by, explore gems and chains, and talk about their design ideas.

Once done, they have the option to pick it up or have it delivered within the day. And if you want, you can even drag your friends in to have matching pieces.

The policies that they have on returns and exchanges are also pretty okay. For instance, we approve of the fact that you can get an exchange or get store credit if there are any manufacturing defects in your items.

We just didn’t like how you can’t get any refunds including the deposits on made-to-order items. But, other than that, we’re fine with everything else they offer.

Pros

  • Specializes in reworking vintage jewellery
  • Features various jewellery collections
  • Free consultations
  • Same-day delivery and free shipping
  • Custom on the spot services available

Cons

  • Minor issues on certain policies
  • Minor issues on customer service

Customer Reviews

A store that has it all

Gorgeous pieces, attention to detail, the dreamiest wrapping for your beautiful items, incredible customer service, they have it all!! Came across this place when walking  around in Ossington and ended up ordering three pieces from them, to say that they didn’t disappoint is an understatement! So HAPPY with my purchase and with this place. – Laura D. L. Cecconello

Unique and beautiful shop

This shop is amazing! It will absolutely be your favourite place to go once you walk inside! The staff is beyond kind every time and genuinely want to make something you will love. I have gotten a few pieces here and love every one of them! I have never found or seen jewellery as unique and beautiful as theirs. – Leah Marche

6. Linara Jewellery

TestInfo
SERVICESReady-made and custom pieces, ethically procured diamonds and rare gems
WEBSITEhttps://linara.ca/
ADDRESS221 Victoria St #309, Toronto, ON M5B 1V4, Canada
CONTACT DETAILS+1 416-509-6797 | [email protected]
OPERATING HOURSBy appointment only

Total Scores

Variety of jewellery pieces★★★★☆ (4/5)
Reputation and credibility★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Customer satisfaction★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Community recommendation★★★★★ (5/5)
Customer service★★★★☆ (4/5)
⮕Staff★★★★★ (5/5)
⮕Shopping experience★★★☆☆ (3/5)
⮕After-care services★★★★★ (5/5)
Guarantees and policies★★★★★ (5/5)

If you’re on the hunt for a jeweler who can work with your creative vision, we believe that Linara Custom Jewellery is the shop for you. They specialize in custom jewelry made from ethically-sourced, conflict-free Canadian diamonds and gemstones. 

We were really impressed by the range of services that Linara offers. Not only are they doing one-of-a-kind pieces for engagement rings, wedding bands, and other one-of-a-kind pieces, but they also help you source diamonds and are doing appraisals.  

Their roster of diamonds would include brand-name diamonds, fancy coloured diamonds, and ethically sourced diamonds. They also have a gorgeous selection of gemstone arts that includes fine and sacred art.

Beyond that, we like that Linara only uses certified and ethically-sourced diamonds. This would mean that the diamonds and gemstones that are used in your pieces are ethically mined and polished on Canadian soil. 

Linara’s jewelers handpick the gems and other sources that they use for their pieces, so you can be sure that your gems are quality. Their pieces are also made from fairtrade gold in Canada that would be well within your budget.

In addition to this, you also get certificates for your piece that ensures its status. This especially foes for rare and usual gems that can be found on your pieces as well.

They have a 3-year warranty available that could be used if ever you need a jewel to replace. All in all, they provide excellent service throughout the process and even after you take possession of the piece.

Pros

  • Specializes in GIA Certified and ethically sourced diamonds
  • Member of the Canadian Gemmological Association and a regulated member of Canadian Jewellery Association
  • Complimentary appointments available
  • 3-year warranty available
  • Sells only certified, eco-friendly, Canadian diamonds
  • Appraisals available

Cons

  • By appointment only
  • No in-stock items
  • Does not offer repair services outside of their own work

Customer Reviews

I’m so glad I found Angela!

I’ve been meaning to get this custom necklace done for so long and I’m so glad I found Angela! I appreciate the time she took to understand exactly what I wanted, she was extremely responsive and kept me up to date throughout the process. The final product turned out exactly as I wanted it and it definitely won’t be the last time I bring my ideas to life with Angela. – Amanda Hassoun

We are very grateful that Linara was recommended to us.

Angela and Sergey were very professional and responsive. The ring came out beautifully, my husband loves the design and how it turned out. She walked us through the whole process, kept us informed through all the stages till the final step. The price is very reasonable, and it didn’t compromise the quality of the ring. We are very grateful that Linara was recommended to us. – Akshika Suriyakumara

7. The Butler Collection

TestInfo
SERVICESJewelery, Bridal, Rings, Necklaces, Earrings, Bracelets, Accessories, Gifts
WEBSITEhttps://thebutlercollection.com/
ADDRESS270 The Kingsway Etobicoke, ON M9A 3T7
CONTACT DETAILSPhone: 416-908-9587
OPERATING HOURSTuesday to Saturday: 11 AM - 5 PM
Variety of jewellery pieces★★★★☆ (4/5)
Reputation and credibility★★★★☆ (4/5) 
⮕Customer satisfaction★★★★☆ (4/5) 
⮕Community recommendation★★★★☆ (4/5) 
Customer service★★★★☆ (4/5) 
⮕Staff★★★★☆ (4/5) 
⮕Shopping experience★★★★☆ (4/5) 
⮕After-care services★★★★☆ (4/5) 
Guarantees and policies★★★★☆ (4/5) 

Next on our list is The Butler Collection. Founded by Heather, the designer, last 2010, their jewelry features fine handcrafted gemstones, pearls, and Swarovski crystals set in sterling silver or 14 and 18 K gold-filled settings.

She sees to it that The Butler Collection offers a fine collection of contemporary and sophisticated jewelry that reflects today’s modern women. Her signature line includes intricate beadwork and rare gemstones. These one-of-a-kind treasures are colorful and imaginative works of wearable art.

It is amazing that they also create one-of-a-kind and limited edition pieces, as well as custom work for weddings. You and your entire bridal party will be stunningly unique in their exquisite jewelry as they also design jewelry for the bride and her entire bridal party.

Pros

  • Offers free and expedited shipping for orders of $99 or more
  • Offers free monthly jewelry drawing

Cons

Customer Reviews

“I have known Heather for a few years now. Heather’s jewelry has seen me through cruises, weddings and my work ensemble. She has such an expert eye for what looks good on women and I admire her for this talent.” – Diane Bremner

“My wife was so happy with my purchase of jewelry. Heather was so helpful in assisting me with my selection. She loves her ring. Definitely will be back.” – Steven Goodman

Heather’s designs are beautiful and always unique. The quality of the gemstone are second to none, with excellent prices.
Whenever I shop there, Heather would always be attentive. I never leave there disappointed.”
– Cherry Hamlet

FAQs About jewellery Stores in Toronto


Are you looking at jewellery stores in Toronto for an upcoming wedding? Let’s help you with other wedding vendors on your special day with the following reviews: