Kandice VincentToys aren’t just for kids– they also provide an escape from the responsibilities of the grown-up world. Our guide explores the best toy stores in Toronto that provide nostalgic classics to cutting-edge gadgets, catering to the inner child within all of us.
So, whether you’re a parent seeking a distraction for your little one or an adult looking for the ultimate stress-relieving fidget, join us on a playful journey through the top toy stores in Toronto. These are realms wherein age is just a number!
How much are toys in Toronto?
Typically, toys in Toronto cost around $20 to $50. The most popular ones include Gabby’s Dollhouse ($50), MGA’s Miniverse Make It Mini Collectibles ($13), the MEGA Pokémon Building Kit ($40), and Play-Doh Kitchen Creations ($30).
How We Chose the Best Toy Stores in Toronto
1. Treasure Island Toys Ltd.
Treasure Island Toys has been a beloved local spot since 1988. Co-owners Katie MacKinnon and Lori Parker, who took the reins in 2010, transformed it into a place for families seeking quality toys and a warm community experience.
The store showcases an impressive array of featured brands, including Brio, Djeco, Lego, and more, spanning ages from 0-12 months to teenagers.
In terms of toys, it has a wide range of offerings, from educational toys and puzzles to putties, dolls, construction kits, board games, collectibles, puppets, and beyond. Meaning, it could be a one-stop-shop for diverse and engaging play experiences.
Beyond toys, Treasure Island Toys takes the stress out of loot bag shopping with their renowned custom-wrapped loot bags– a hit among party-goers!
Pros
- 35 years of experience
- Carries several featured brands
- Has toys for all ages
- Wide range of toy types
- Offers loot bag packages
- Has street and bike parking
Cons
- A bit pricey
- Aisles might be a bit cramped during peak season
My go-to for buying gifts for my daughter and nieces
“First time to explore this fun store on Danforth. Organized, bright and clean. Cute decors. It’s definitely a hidden gem in the community. Treasure Island Toys has an excellent selection of toys for all ages. They provide many different kinds of board games, activities, the cutest plush toys, stationeries, books and many more. Prices are really competitive compared with Amazon and Walmart. Great customer service. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We only got something small yesterday but will definitely come back. This lovely toy store will become my go-to for buying gifts for my daughter and nieces. Highly recommended buying here and supporting a local store.”
Shirley Cheng, Google Review
Lots of amazing things for kids and adults
“Arrrrrr, the pirate ship drew me in. Went here to find some things for my brother’s kids. Lots of amazing things for kids and adults. They prices are better then I thought by far. Wish I was able to go in the pirate ship. But can’t have it all. Thank you for your toys.”
John Harbic, Google Review
2. The Swag Sisters’ Toy Store
Situated in Little India’s Bazaar, The Swag Sisters’ Toy Store is a neighborhood hub founded by Erin Salisbury and her husband Guy Bagley. Raised in the same community, they opened the store in 2011 after noticing a gap and a need for a local toy store.
The store has an impressive array of toy brands, including Djeco, Hape, Just Jump It, Kidoozie, The Spooner, and Waboba, ensuring a diverse and high-quality selection.
From budget-friendly animal-free builds starting at $5.99 to Star Wars 75308 R2-D2 collectibles priced at $299.99, they cater to every budget and interest.
Additionally, the store offers a personalized touch with custom gift cards and a rewarding loyalty program. Customers can create an account that translates to earning points for every dollar spent—redeemable for rewards and discounts.
Pros
- Over a decade of experience
- Offers quality toy brands
- Wide range of toys at various price points
- Personalized gift cards
- Loyalty rewards program
Cons
- Reports of rude staff
- Very narrow aisles
So patient with kids’ questions and will help you find what you need
“This toy store is a real gem. They are knowledgeable, and care about their community — the best kind of local business! They’re so patient with kids’ questions, and will help you find whatever you need. My kids love going to browse, but we always walk out with some new treasures. And as an added bonus, they continue to prioritize safety and accessibility for everyone. The best!”
Emily Mousseau-Douglas, Google Review
Guy absolutely NAILED his gift suggestion!
“10/10 store. Went in looking for a gift for my non-verbal autistic, developmentally delayed step sister. Guy absolutely NAILED his gift suggestion!! She has been playing the Zingo game non-stop for the past hour (practically unheard of type of response!) They really know their stuff here and stock the most wonderful options. Fave place on the strip. THANK YOU!!”
Kristin Light, Google Review
3. Mastermind Toys
Established in 1984, Mastermind Toys has blossomed into one of Canada’s must-visit spots for play. With 66 locations nationwide, Mastermind Toys stands as the country’s largest specialty toy and children’s book retailer.
The store caters to every budget, offering a wide range of toys, from $5 LEGO mini-figures to a $330 Newtonian reflector telescope. Beyond its expansive selection, this toy shop offers complimentary gift wrapping with every purchase.
They even offer corporate services. Their dedicated Corporate Concierge and in-store Play Experts specialize in customizing experiences suitable for every event, big or small.
For innovators with a passion for play, Mastermind Toys invites toy and book applications through their toy submissions program. It’s a platform that helps toy creators showcase their products.
Pros
- Over 30 years of experience
- Complimentary gift wrapping
- Has a Perks Birthday Kids program
- Wide range of toys for all ages with different prices
- Has a Corporate Concierge and in-store Play Experts
- Has a toy submission program
Cons
- Lack of responsiveness to online queries
- Reports of rude staff
Incredible service and friendly staff
“Incredible service, and friendly staff. Was pleasantly surprised when I passed the store last week in the beaches. I also just learned recently The mastermind Toys is one of the largest Canadian toy company’s. And this specific locations been open for the last 35 years!”
Mark Zilio, Google Review
Wonderful staff who were very kind and patient
“I would like to thank the wonderful staff who were so very kind and patient with me today as I had a mishap and it left me very stressed. I appreciated your thoughtfulness so very much!”
Linda Rieser, Google Review
4. The Playful Peacock
The Playful Peacock proudly claims the title of Canada’s number one eco toy store. The business was born out of Anne’s journey during the pandemic, realizing the profound impact of simple, open-ended play on her child’s engagement.
It curates Montessori-inspired, wooden toys, and open-ended play products from craftspeople and small family shops around the world.
What sets them apart is their focus on sustainability and ethics – none of their toys rely on batteries or plastic, and every product is ethically made and sustainably sourced.
Plus, their packaging is 99% plastic-free, biodegradable, recyclable, and compostable.
With their own children serving as the “official” toy testers, every product at their store is kid-approved.
Beyond play, the store partners with Canadian Feed the Children to support food security initiatives in 26 Indigenous communities across Canada.
Pros
- Specialises in Montessori-inspired wooden toys
- Also offers open-ended play products
- Has a focus on sustainability and ethics
- “Toy testers” are kids
- Offers 10% off your first order
Cons
- Comparatively limited range of toys
- Pricey
Such beautiful heirloom pieces, many of which are made in Canada!
“I have made several purchases from the Playful Peacock and have loved everything! Such beautiful heirloom pieces, many of which are even made in Canada! The owner, Anne, is amazing, kind and so helpful. She answered all my questions and shipped it all very quickly!!”
Natalie Fatica, Google Review
By far my favourite toy store of all time!
“This is by far my favourite toy store of all time! On top of selling top notch toys, Anne is the greatest! Quick to reply, so helpful and always answers my insane questions 🙂 I highly recommend and will continue to order again and again!”
A Dame, Google Review
5. Kol Kid
Kol Kid is the brainchild of owner Lisa Miyasaki, who opened this innovative children’s boutique in 1999.
Her journey began with the birth of her first son, Kol, who was born with special needs. This propelled her into the world of toys, leading her to curate a selection that aids in achieving developmental milestones.
It offers an array of treasures, from toys and baby gear to the latest trends in baby and children’s apparel. Brands like Bobo Choses, Mini Rodini, 1 + in the family, and Nununu grace the shelves.
They also have an extensive collection of kids’ shoes, featuring names like New Balance, Native Shoes, Salt Water Sandals, Naturino, and Hunter. As a bonus, they extend free shipping for orders totaling $125 or more before taxes.
The boutique also offers the convenience of a gift registry and gift cards.
Pros
- Over 20 years of experience
- Specializes in educational and developmental toys
- Offers toys, baby gear, an apparel
- Wide selection of branded shoes
- Free shipping for orders from $125 up before taxes
- Has a gift registry and gift cards
Cons
- Ships within Canada only
- Not wheelchair-friendly
Such a nice store with a great selection!
“Such a nice store with a great selection! Hazuki and the manager provided me with such great service! They helped me get the sneakers I’ve been after for my little one before they sold out! They arrived at my house so quickly and we’re absolutely perfect.”
Beverly Ortencio, Google Review
Well curated collection of products for little ones
“Fantastic find!! Well curated collection of products for little ones. Quality customer service – associates seemed happy to help and provided a quick fix to an error that I made during an online order. Items ordered online arrived quickly. Highly recommend :).”
Alexis Gavaris, Google Review
