Brianna HarrisonFrom simple bands used in ancient Egypt to sparkling diamond rings popularized by De Beers, engagement rings have always told a love story. It’s not just a piece of jewellery—it’s a symbol of commitment and devotion.
To help you seal the deal in style, we rounded up the best engagement ring shops in Toronto. These pros will help you secure a resounding “Yes.” Good luck!
How much do engagement rings cost in Toronto?
Engagement rings in Toronto typically cost from $1,500 to $6,000, depending on the diamond quality, setting, and brand.
Many local jewellers offer flexible options, from lab-grown diamonds to custom designs, which can significantly affect pricing.
1. Kimberfire
Business Address: 27 Queen St E #1204
Website: https://www.kimberfire.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/kimberfire/
Contact Details: +1 416-861-8110
Business Hours: Mon – Fri: 10 AM–6 PM
Since 2013, Kimberfire has managed to hit the sweet spot between the convenience of online engagement ring shopping and the high-end feel of a boutique. So, it’s no surprise they’ve been named as one of the best jewellery stores in Toronto.
How they source their diamonds is what really makes them stand out—they work directly with manufacturers to cut out inventory costs. Their natural stones are GIA or AGS-certified, and their lab-grown ones have GIA or IGI certification.
That focus on quality flows into their custom design process. If you have a specific vision (or budget!) in mind, their team uses 3D rendering to bring your dream ring to life.
To make the deal even sweeter, they offer a complimentary lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects, which we think is pretty cool.
Note that because they’re a local favourite, snagging a consultation can be tricky.
The perfect place to buy an engagement ring
“If you have been searching for the perfect place to buy an engagement ring and stumbled across Kimberfire, you can end your search now! My friend suggested Kimberfire to me, and I am so happy that he did! When I started my search for an engagement ring at various retail stores, I was overwhelmed by the sheer number of stores and the at-times pushy nature of their sales staff. My experience with Jonathan at Kimberfire could not have been more different. From my initial consultation with Jonathan through to the pickup of the completed ring, he was professional, courteous, and extremely helpful throughout the entire process…Jonathan was able to help guide me to the perfect ring to suit her personality and style. In the end, the product exceeded my expectations in every way. The value and quality of the ring I ended up with were far more than I would have ever received at one of the retail outlets for the same price. Most importantly, my fiancée absolutely loves it and says it is “perfect!” She has told me already that we will be going back there for our wedding bands. I would highly recommend Kimberfire to anyone looking to buy a ring. They are a smaller outlet, so it may take a short wait to get in for your first appointment, but it is definitely worth any wait.”
– Matthew Stam, Google Review
Breathtaking, balanced, & beautifully crafted
“A flawless experience from start to finish with Kimberfire. The team took my vision for my wife’s engagement ring and elevated it with INCREDIBLE attention to detail—everything from stone selection to the tiniest design accents felt thoughtfully considered. They worked within my short timeline without cutting a single corner, kept me updated at every step, and delivered ahead of schedule. I especially appreciated their clear, collaborative process: they listened first, offered expert guidance (with renders and options), and earned my trust with transparent communication and zero pressure. The ring is breathtaking, guys!!!—balanced, beautifully crafted, and exactly what we hoped for. My now wife is over the moon, and she STILL shows it off to me months after we got married, haha, I couldn’t be happier. Five billion star rating without hesitation. Ask for Shani, she’s literally a champion.”
– Mohammed Sule, Google Review
2. Anne Sportun Jewellery
Business Address: 742 Queen St W
Website: https://www.annesportun.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/annesportun/
Contact Details: +1 416-363-4114
Business Hours:
- Mon – Sat: 11 AM–6 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM–5 PM
Anne Sportun started as a teen hobbyist before refining her craft through formal goldsmithing training and opening her brand in the late 80s. Now, she co-owns the shop with her daughter, Haley, who serves as the Custom Design Specialist.
Their artistic DNA is obvious when you browse their “One of a Kind Engagement Ring Collection.” They feature everything, from classic rounds and ovals to moody marquises.
If custom is more your vibe, they offer a design service where their team works closely with you to come up with a look. You’ll even get to approve a high-tech 3D CAD rendering.
The shop’s master goldsmiths will then handcraft your custom piece, which typically takes around six to eight weeks.
While their jewellery itself is breathtaking, we heard that their staff members can come across as a little brusque or rude.
Designs are beautiful, unique, and timeless
“Dean and I had the absolute best experience with Alexa at the shop, and we so recommend shopping here to any couple looking for engagement rings!!! When we first visited Anne Sportun, we had a limited understanding of the process and what cut/clarity/colour meant, so we were a little intimidated, but Alexa was so warm and welcoming and did such a good job educating us on what we needed to know. The designs are BEAUTIFUL, unique, and timeless, and I especially loved that it was a one-of-a-kind engagement ring. Alexa guided us perfectly and helped us find my dream ring based on our ideas; she truly went above and beyond. Alexa made us feel so calm and welcome while never making us feel pressured to make a decision. She wanted us to find the perfect engagement ring, and we 100% did. Thank you so much to Alexa and the staff, and I can’t wait to visit the shop to look at wedding bands.”
– Jeslyn Chantler, Google Review
Made me the most beautiful 3-stone engagement ring
“AS holds a special place in my heart. They worked with my fiancé to make me the most beautiful 3-stone engagement ring, as well as sold me the most perfect everyday gold hoops. The customer service is unmatched, and they make gorgeous pieces. Truly creating heirloom-worthy jewelry.”
– Sarah Hilborn, Google Review
3. Made You Look
Business Address: 1338 Queen St W
Website: https://www.madeyoulook.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/madeyoulookjewellery/
Contact Details: +1 416-463-2136
Business Hours:
- Mon – Fri: 10 AM–8 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM–5 PM
Made You Look is a curated gallery and studio that represents over 100 Canadian jewellery designers known for distinctive engagement and wedding rings. No wonder they were recipients of the 2025 Canadian Jewellery Association Impact Award.
When it comes to engagement rings, they have a diverse selection. You can choose from diamonds, sapphires, rubies, or moissanite, or browse by style: solitaire, halo, etc.
Those with a specific vision in mind would need to choose a designer first and set up a meeting, either in one of the private rooms or via Zoom.
To round things out, they offer solid aftercare perks. Repairs due to defects in materials or craftsmanship are done free of charge, and ring resizing is complimentary right after purchase or first wear.
Unfortunately, we learned that some shoppers do find prices on the higher side.
Engagement ring selection was stunning to browse!
“I recently visited the shop for the first time today. I was looking for a simple gold ring to start my collection. I found what I was looking for. Great customer service, and so many options to pick from. Their engagement ring selection was also stunning to browse!”
– Amy, Google Review
Created the perfect custom ring exactly as desired
“Incredible service and nice products! We shopped around a lot for an engagement ring, and the service we received from all the Made You Look staff, as well as our designer, Tony Leung, was exceptional. They helped us through the entire process, and Tony created the perfect custom ring exactly as desired. Every step from the 3D renders to the final appraisal, the interactions couldn’t have been better. Highly recommend! -Ashetsha”
– 9Block Productions, Google Review
4. Carnabys Bespoke Jewellery
Business Address: 171 E Liberty St unit 135
Website: https://www.carnabys.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/carnabysbespoke/
Contact Details: +1 416-792-4992
Business Hours:
- Tue – Fri: 10:30 AM–6 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–4 PM
Carnabys Bespoke Jewellery is a direct homage to the iconic Carnaby Street—the legendary birthplace of “Swinging London.” Just like its namesake, the brand is built on a foundation of bold creative expression.
That London-inspired flair translates perfectly into their bespoke services. They’ll analyze your personality, aesthetic, and daily lifestyle to create a stunning yet practical engagement ring.
As for materials, they’re dedicated to giving you that ethical sparkle. The team only uses conflict-free diamonds, as well as sustainable lab-grown ones; they can even source specific stones from their global partners if needed.
Private consultations are available to guide you through the diamond-buying journey, complete with diamond education, so you feel confident in your decision.
One thing you need to remember—their in-house engagement ring selection is fairly limited, as the brand leans heavily toward custom work.
10/10 – so perfect, so sparkly, & perfectly fitted
“Geoff made my wedding band dreams come true! My fiancé had Geoff create my engagement ring flawlessly, so we knew we had to go back for our wedding bands. I had a bit of an unconventional style/request from a standard band, and the final result was an absolute 10/10 – so perfect, so sparkly, perfectly fitted, and now I’m struggling with the fact that I have to wait to wear it. If you’re looking for a jeweller, truly just go here – all the reviews before me are not exaggerating.”
– Natalee O’Connor, Google Review
My fiancé absolutely loves her ring
“I worked with Geoff (the owner) on designing an engagement ring for my now fiancé. He was knowledgeable and helpful, walking me through the entire process. On my first visit to the store, we spent an hour going through ring ideas and diamonds while getting to know each other, and I knew I was in the right hands! My fiancé absolutely loves her ring, and we will definitely be using Carnabys for our wedding bands! Thank you for a great experience, Geoff!”
– Nik Rogan, Google Review
5. Be-Jewelled
Business Address: 1485 Dupont St #207
Website: https://be-jewelled.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bejewelled_toronto/
Contact Details: +1 416-551-5523
Business Hours:
- Tue – Sat: 11 AM–7 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM–7 PM
Founded by brothers Mandeep and Sumeet Singh in 2015, Be-Jewelled is actually backed by four generations of craftsmanship dating back to the early 1900s.
This legacy of skill shows through in their user-friendly design process; you start with a stunning setting and find a perfect stone center to match. They even encourage touches like custom engravings or birthstones.
With every ring purchase, you receive an original diamond certificate from the GIA or IGI—proof of the stone’s cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight, plus a third-party independent appraisal.
We love that the support continues long after the proposal via their Limited Lifetime Warranty that covers any defects in materials. As a supplement, they have a Lifetime Upgrade policy if you ever want to go bigger down the road.
Obviously, since they’re focused on bespoke engagement rings, don’t expect a massive showroom of ready-to-wear rings.
I am in love with my engagement ring!
“I am in love with my engagement ring! The process was so smooth and timely. The team was amazing to work with! They were patient, collaborative, and really listened to my ideas. We had a lot of back and forth, and they were always so responsive and supportive throughout the process. They truly brought my vision to life, and I couldn’t be happier with the final result. Highly recommend!”
– Jas & Sunny, Google Review
Be-jewelled created my dream engagement ring with such care and detail.
“Be-jewelled created my dream engagement ring with such care and detail. The craftsmanship is stunning, and the team made the whole process effortless. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a truly special piece!!!”
– Mahima Saini, Google Review
