Kandice VincentMy cousin recently started her own bakery, and for her grand opening, she went all out with branded merch—t-shirts, mugs, tote bags, and, of course, custom pins.
The opening was a hit, and now, months later, I still spot her adorable pins on people’s jackets and backpacks around town.
It got me thinking—custom pins aren’t just cool giveaways or campaign tools; they can be a key part of branding. For those launching a business, hosting an event, or just wanting to add a little flair, custom pins are a fun way to make a lasting impression.
With that in mind, here are the best custom pin makers in Toronto!
How much do custom pins cost in Toronto?
The cost of custom pins in Toronto can range from $1.50 to $5 per pin, with bulk orders often reducing the per-pin cost. Prices typically depend on factors like the size, design complexity, quantity, and materials used.
Additional customizations, like enamel finishes or unique backings, can increase the price.
1. Crucial Pins
Crucial Pins has been a go-to for custom buttons and magnets since 2002, and it’s easy to see why. They can typically turn orders around within 24-48 hours. In fact, if you’re in a rush, there’s even the possibility of same-day pick-up.
We like their super straightforward ordering process; download their templates, prepare your design, and email them the file—as simple as that! But if your design isn’t already set up, they’ll charge a $20 setup fee.
They offer different pin sizes as well, from 1 inch to 3 inches. And their order minimums are flexible—starting at just 10 to 24 pins for smaller orders, but they can handle quantities all the way up to over 10,000 pins if needed.
One area for improvement, though, would be their communication. Some customers told us that they didn’t always get prompt responses to their queries.
Incredibly fast, the price was amazing, and the pick-up was easy
“Warren from Crucial Pins was amazing to work with; very responsive to all my questions, both over the phone and through email, the turnaround for getting my pins made was incredibly fast, the price was amazing and the pick-up was easy. I will not hesitate to work with him again. Highly recommend.”
Bethany Jolliffe, Google Review
Incredible customer service and high-quality pins
“When I needed pins, Crucial Pins was there with incredible customer service and high quality pins in a timely fashion. I’m looking forward to needing more pins soon!”
Brett Steckle, Google Review
2. Artik Promotional Products
Artik Promotional Products has been around since 1985. Now, they’ve grown into one of the city’s go-to printing businesses, offering a wide range of custom products, including their popular custom pin-back buttons.
You can choose from round, oval, rectangular, or square custom buttons. They can also feature your logo, name, or any custom text, making them perfect for all sorts of events (e.g. corporate affairs, school conferences, tradeshow, political campaigns, etc.).
As a bonus, they do most of their work in-house, which helps keep costs down and pass those savings on to their customers.
We also like their satisfaction guarantee; if they make a mistake on your order, they’ll either redo the job or offer a discount or refund—no hassle.
However, some customers have pointed out that the receptionist can be a bit rude, which might leave a bad taste during an otherwise smooth process.
Top quality work and really helpful staff!
“Top quality work and really helpful staff! Highly recommend!”
Tory Woollcott, Google Review
Quality and customer care is beyond exceptional
“I LOVE these guys!!!! Ryan S. is the most helpful sales representative I have ever dealt with and the quality and customer care is beyond exceptional. 10 stars!!! Highly recommend Artik.”
Andrea Hillo, Google Review
3. Sira Print Inc.
Sira Print is a great option if you’re looking for a simple and convenient way to buy custom printing products online. Their specialty is custom acrylic pins—designed to be durable enough to withstand daily wear and tear.
To order, all you need to do is upload your design or use their online design tool to create something unique. Then, simply choose the size, shape, and quantity of pins you need, review your order, and submit it.
Plus, they offer free PDF proofs so you can see exactly what your pins will look like before they go to print.
Another perk is that they offer free shipping within Canada and the U.S., with most orders ready in just 5 days.
That said, we noticed that their pricing is a bit high. For example, the minimum order of 10 pins will cost you a whopping $41.33.
They respond fast and get my orders shipped so fast too!
“Very very satisfied! Every order I have made with Siraprint has been a delight! They respond fast and get my orders shipped so fast too! Everyone at Siraprint has my respect and I hope to continue using their service! Thank you always for great service and the extras!!<3”
truebladearts, Google Review
Been working with these guys for years and they never fail me
“I have been working with these guys for years and they never fail me. They always come through with the final product on time and at a reasonable price. They use all different types of materials and are good at helping to create awesome designs. Can’t recommend them enough.”
Josh Mandel, Google Review
4. ButtonBoy
ButtonBoy is a proudly Canadian company with over 20 years of experience in the button-making business. They’ve carved out a solid niche for themselves by specializing in custom-made promotional buttons.
If you don’t have a button image or are struggling with ideas, there’s no need to worry! They offer to create a custom button image for free based on your concept.
After you provide the details, they’ll send you proof via email so you can review and approve the design. You can then choose from 1-inch to 2.25-inch pins, which cover the most popular sizes for promotional buttons.
It’s also refreshing to know that they don’t impose any minimum or maximum order quantities. They even offer bulk order discounts!
For anyone in the GTA, they can complete a rush order in three days or less. Note, however, that there have been some reports of unaccomplished paid orders.
Buttons were done to perfection and in time!
“We ordered 30 buttons for a rush job. The buttons were done to perfection and in time! The customer service was impeccable! What a great experience! Thanks again guys!”
Leanna Taylor, Google Review
Each turned out high quality
“TJ and co are amazing! My order was fulfilled and shipped quickly and seamlessl. I had two versions of buttons made and each turned out high quality and exactly how I wanted. Our family and friends were so delighted to see the effort that was put into production. The follow up from the team to ensure my requests was fulfilled as requested was above and beyond what I expected. Thank you for you for everything button boy team ❤️”
Nichola H, Google Review
5. Stitchy Lizard
Stitchy Lizard has been a well-known name in the promotional product business since June 2002. They offer a wide range of services including custom pins, embroidery, and screen printing.
They specialize in a variety of pin types, including enamel pin badges, personalized pin badges, and bespoke business promotional items. They can create branded products for employee gifts, unique corporate logo merchandise, or just something personal.
As a bonus, they have an in-house graphic design team that’ll work closely with you to create enamel pins that align perfectly with your brand and business. They can help you with a custom design for a corporate logo or even fun liquid-filled lapel pins.
It’s no wonder their work has been featured in Toronto Life Magazine.
Unfortunately, we heard some reports about a rude owner, which is something to be aware of.
The quality of their work is great
“I’ve been a customer for about 8 years or so. Simon has been taking care of my account for quite a while now. He’s been exceptional and even though I’m not a high-volume customer, he treats me like I’m their biggest client! The quality of their work is great so I don’t have anything but good things to say! Thanks to you all!”
Nadim R, Google Review
Fantastic at answering any questions/concerns
“Amazing service! I have been in contact with Stitchy Lizard for the past couple of months finalizing some large orders. Simon was fantastic at answering any questions/concerns we may have had. We fully trusted their guidance and recommendations when suggesting products. We will definitely be working with them again in the near future. P.s I highly recommend checking out their showroom! They have great products.”
Arrun Joll, Google Review
