Aliu IsaI’m not going to pretend that I don’t buy milk and cheese from the grocery store. But whenever I feel like giving myself a treat, I visit a dairy farm in and around the city.
Yes, there’s a big difference: the flavor is richer, the textures are creamier, and the products are made with care by people who know the cows by name! Plus, many of these farms offer tours, tastings, and fun extras like homemade ice cream.
Ready to go beyond the grocery aisle? Here are the best Toronto dairy farms that I always hit up for that fresh, local goodness.
How much do farm-fresh dairy products cost in Toronto?
Farm-fresh dairy products in Toronto usually start around $3 to $5 for milk and $8 or more for artisan cheese.
These prices reflect the small-batch quality, local sourcing, and extra care that goes into production. Butter, yogurt, and other dairy treats also tend to be priced a bit higher than supermarket brands.
1. Summit Station Dairy & Creamery
Summit Station Dairy & Creamery is a Copetown farm nestled on land bought by Joe in 1947. It has since grown from just 15 Holstein cows to a fourth-generation operation run by his grandson.
I love that it has serious street cred. It was recognized with the Hamilton Chamber of Commerce’s Ironman Award and regularly ranked among Canada’s Top 10 Best Managed Dairy Herds.
And you know that classic ad, ‘Got Milk?’ Well, that they do—from whole, 2%, and unhomogenized to chocolate and strawberry. They even sell delicious bottled cream.
You can buy them online, or better yet, visit their on-farm store, where you can see cheese curds being made via a viewing window. They even have a dairy bar, where you can sip milk or coffee paired with freshly baked cookies or ice cream—yum!
Just watch out for a few staff members who might be a bit unfriendly.
Beautiful dairy farm shop
“Beautiful dairy farm shop. An amazing array of items from cheese curds to flavoured milk. My husband, who does not like coffee, added the coffee flavour to his hot chai, which also elevated my coffee to a whole new level. I foamed the coffee flavour and added it to the coffee, the best! All the flavours are wonderful. I highly recommend the butterscotch ice cream! We are very fortunate in southern Ontario!”
Carolyn Emma, Google Review
Very nice facility & great products
“Modern and country at the same time! There’s something special about enjoying a cold bottle of milk while you stand next to the cows that made it. Very nice facility and great products. Plenty of parking for the busy summer days and lots of places to sit around the building to enjoy the tasty treats. A wonderful place to visit while out for a country drive with the family or grab a couple of bottles of milk for the week.”
Ryan Cantin, Google Review
2. Eby Manor Farm
Since 1959, Eby Manor has been a family-run farm in Waterloo Region. Jim and Ruthy Eby, along with other family members, have kept the legacy alive with their beloved Guernsey cows.
Yep, they have 60 registered milking bovines, known for producing dairy that’s 100% A2—a type that many people with lactose sensitivities find easier to digest. They offer three kinds: 4.8% non-homogenized and 2%, as well as 4% chocolate milk.
Customers rave about their Guernsey cheese and all-natural Balkan-style yogurt as well, with some even driving for over an hour to stock up.
Excited to try their goodies? You can grab all of their products at Eby’s Dairy Market, located on the farm, including ice cream, summer sausage, and Guernsey beef.
Just a heads up—they only accept cash and debit cards.
Best chocolate milk I’ve ever tasted!
“Best chocolate milk I’ve ever tasted! Fresh, delicious, and the bottle is so cute. Perfect for daily use and even for gifts this holiday season. 100/10! 🌟”
Joyce Uy, Google Review
Delivers rich, creamy flavor and freshness
“Eby Manor’s pasteurized milk is an exceptional product that delivers rich, creamy flavor and freshness that stands out from standard grocery options. Highly recommended for anyone looking to elevate their milk experience with locally sourced, carefully crafted dairy products!”
Celso Jr Salon, Google Review
3. Sheldon Creek Dairy
Located in the beautiful Sheldon Valley, Sheldon Creek Dairy is definitely worth the trip.
Their herd of 75 Holstein cows is specially bred for A2A2 genetics, which means the milk they produce is free of A1 proteins. So, not only is it creamy and tasty, but it’s also easier on the tummy.
Of course, they carry your staples like whole, skim, and chocolate milk, but they also offer unique flavors like banana, orange creamsicle, and even pina colada. And if you’re into cultured dairy, yogurt and kefir are available at their on-site farm store, too.
What’s cool is that they have wholesale options as well. So, if you’re looking to stock up for your home or small business, they have you covered.
Unfortunately, we heard isolated reports of the milk tasting a little watery at times, depending on the batch.
A2 milk is always fresh and non-homogenized
“I like their storefront and the products they have from their own dairy and from other local suppliers. Their A2 milk is always fresh and non-homogenized. They sell amazing chocolate milk, both in A2 and regular versions. The diary is in a peaceful location away from the city. It’s worth a drive on the weekends to grab some of the goodies. Some of the milk and meat items are on sale once in a while. I haven’t tasted their ice cream yet as the stall was closed during the times I visited the dairy farm.”
Sumanth J, Google Review
Their dairy products are beyond delicious
“Oh. My. Gosh. Their flavored milks and dairy products are beyond delicious. I’m always excitedly awaiting the new flavored milk of the month. Such a treat!”
Sara N, Google Review
4. Mapleton’s Organic Dairy
Mapleton’s Organic Dairy is a family-run farm that does everything in a sustainable way. They grow their own feed, compost their manure, and use it to enrich the fields, making sure their dairy herd is well taken care of.
Their on-farm milk self-serve dispenser is a big highlight. Just bring your own jug or grab one onsite and fill it up with fresh, pasteurized, and homogenized organic milk for just $3.50 per liter—they even have a rewards program, making your 7th liter free!
Beyond milk, their premium ice cream is a big crowd-pleaser. And for something lighter, you can try their vanilla or strawberry frozen yogurt (my favorite!).
Feel free to bring the kids since the farm accepts visitors for only $5 per person.
One downside we heard about—some guests have noted that staff can come across as a bit rude.
In love with Mapleton’s Organic Dairy
“This welcoming, educational, honest, caring place far exceeded all hopes for fun and excitement for the whole family. I am in love with Mapleton’s Organic petting zoo, dairy, creamery, fresh milk, impressive ice cream, butter tarts, local cheeses and honeys, humongous cedar maze/pirate ship, and play slide experience zoo! And we tried Everything we could!”
Kathy Wilson, Google Review
Best organic ice cream
“Best organic ice cream 🍦, it is a place that you can bring the whole family! Kids will love it 😍 here because they have animals that you can see. You can also watch the 🐄 how they are milked by machines. It is very interesting. I have been here many times in the summer, and it is really nice 👍 to get out of town. We drive from Kitchener to come here and get organic ice cream 🍨 get all your family and treat them with a fabulous ice cream 🍦 and much more!!!!”
Dana Mihut, Google Review
5. Schmucker’s Fresh From The Farm
For over 20 years, Schmucker’s Fresh From The Farm has been partnering with Ontario Mennonite and Amish family farmers to bring wholesome products around. And their dairy offerings are no exception.
They carry a fantastic range of Harmony Organic Milk, which comes in returnable glass bottles or 4-liter bags. You can choose from 1%, 2%, full-fat, non-homogenized, or chocolate-vanilla options.
For those who struggle with dairy, they also carry 100% Guernsey milk from Eby Manor, which is easier to digest. Even co-owner Jacquie swears by it herself!
And while you’re there, you might as well stock up on artisan butter, cheese, yogurt, and even goat and sheep milk products.
Sure, some might think their items are a tad pricey. But no one can argue that their product quality is top-notch.
Absolute best for organic meats and dairy
“The absolute best for organic and natural meats and dairy. Have been a customer since opening and enjoy saying hi to Jacqui and the friendly staff each week.”
Darryl Seal, Google Review
Excellent locally sourced produce, meats, & dairy!
“Amazing selection of excellent locally sourced produce, meats, and dairy! Their own foods, made with the same products they sell are also exceptional. The staff are very friendly and always go out of their way to accommodate. I’m very fortunate to have them in my neighborhood!”
Jim F, Google Review
