Kandice VincentOrdering a custom cake for my niece’s birthday seemed like the easiest way to earn “Best Aunt Ever” status. Until the Peppa Pig cake I ordered came back.
I mean, it did look like a pig, but not the British kind; more like the farm animal kind. My niece stared in polite confusion while the adults tried not to laugh—I was mortified!
That day, I learned that not all custom cake shops rise to the occasion.
To save you from the same frosting fiasco, here are the best custom cake shops in Toronto that’ll actually deliver what you asked for.
How much do custom cakes cost in Toronto?
Custom cakes in Toronto typically range from about $50 to $200 or more, depending on size, design complexity, and the bakery’s reputation.
A one-tier cake with minimal decor will be on the lower end, while multi-tiered or highly detailed cakes can push the price much higher. Factors like premium ingredients, intricate fondant work, and last-minute orders can also add to the cost.
1. Cake It Toronto
Cake It Toronto is a local bakery known for stunning custom cakes that taste just as amazing as they look.
You’ll start with a consultation to chat about flavors, fillings, and aesthetics. For instance, you can choose from classic chocolate and vanilla to unique Dubai offerings like Chocolate, Cookie, or Mousse.
Next, you’ll specify the size, shape, and details of your dream cake, and their skilled in-house decorators will then match your theme with custom colors and patterns. They even offer an edible image print service.
Once you’re happy with the sketch they provide based on your input, they’ll go ahead and bake it for you.
Just make sure that you’re okay with their pricing, since we heard that they’re more expensive compared to other bakeries.
The detail on the cake was fantastic
“My mother purchased a “messy room” cake for my birthday. The detail on the cake was fantastic, as well as the cake itself! The price was very decent, as well. Highly recommend! Will definitely come back!”
Ariella Boltinsky, Google Review
Design and the flavor are both top-notch
“Amazing bakery! I ordered a custom cake, and it was so beautifully made. The design and the flavor are both top-notch. Would gladly recommend Cakeittoronto to everybody, especially for custom cakes. Love the detailing and colors of my cake. It was for my son’s 3rd birthday, and it turned out to be awesome!”
Nooreen Fatima, Google Review
2. Bake Me Happy
Craving a custom buttercream cake? Bake Me Happy is the place to go.
Known for their elegant, minimalist style, they create cakes for weddings, baby showers, birthdays, and more. But they’re also experts in whimsical designs inspired by The Aristocrats, Peter Rabbit, Disney princesses, and even Wicked.
They’ll start by helping you brainstorm ideas for your dream cake, guiding you through themes and colors.
And when it comes to flavors, you’ll find classics like buttercream and chocolate-vanilla alongside strawberry shortcake and pistachio. As per previous customers, every cake is moist, balanced in sweetness, and finished with precision.
Once your design is confirmed, they’ll bake your cake and deliver it right on time to your chosen location.
Just a heads up—their work is intricate and in demand, so you’ll want to book well in advance.
Hands down my favorite custom cake ever!!
“Hands down my favorite custom cake ever!! Not only was it beautiful, but it was also delicious. Saili was super knowledgeable, creative, and communicative; she was an absolute pleasure to work with. I will 100% be ordering more.”
Angela Yu, Google Review
Beautiful to look at and delicious to taste
“I ordered a mermaid cake for my daughter’s third birthday, and it was absolutely perfect. Beautiful to look at and delicious to taste. Thank you for your quick responses via Instagram, too.”
Lydia Wood , Google Review
3. Another Slice: Custom Cakes by Wafa
Another Slice is run by Wafa, who started baking at just nine years old. She has since traveled to 17 countries, bringing global inspiration to every creation.
In terms of flavor, they offer a plethora, from classic vanilla with salted caramel filling to unique choices like orange spice cake. You can enjoy Oreo frosting, beach-inspired cakes, or decadent vintage wedding chocolate, too.
We also like their wide range of designs, which you can check out on their online portfolio. Kids would love their Paw Patrol and Hannah Montana cakes, while others would enjoy record player-shaped creations and glittery zodiac constellations.
They offer all types of colors and can create a mix for you. But be forewarned—we heard about the occasional color mismatches.
Looked gorgeous and tasted delicious
“Wafa made wedding cakes for both my sons’ weddings. Beautifully executed. They were delivered on time, looked gorgeous, and tasted delicious. The flavours were rich, especially the orange spice cake, and it was quite clear that quality ingredients had been used. Would recommend without reservations.”
Nazia Tauseef, Google Review
Couldn’t be happier with how it turned out
“We ordered our wedding cake from Wafa and couldn’t be happier with how it turned out. The design was elegant and beautiful, and the chocolate, vanilla, and orange spice flavours were all so delicious. The cake was perfectly balanced, moist, and not overly sweet. The entire experience was worry-free, and we got so many compliments from our guests – we’ll definitely be ordering again. Thank you!”
Natasha Petzold, Google Review
4. CakeStar
It started with Nicola, a baker who shared his pastry expertise with his three daughters. In 2010, one of them, Monja, took that legacy further and opened CakeStar.
First, pick your pound cake base from a variety of flavors like classic chocolate and limonata to adventurous picks like pistachio, tiramisu, or orange chocolate brandy.
Next, you’ll select a delicious cake filling. A popular combo is their Italian Meringue buttercream paired with salted caramel, banana cream, or raspberry white chocolate.
As for design, you can choose from Rosette, Sprinkle, or Ruffle. Sizes, accents, and messages are customizable, too, with optional upgrades like edible images and custom-shaped numbers.
While they do offer a wide range of customization and add-on options, you might want to watch out for disappointing execution issues.
CakeStar bakers are the best!
“CakeStar bakers are the best! The Beatles cake they made for my husband’s 65th was FAB. It exceeded all expectations. The reaction from every guest and the guest of honour was WOW! While it seemed a shame to slice into such a work of art, we broke down and enjoyed every bite. The buttercream is perfection.”
Erika Aucoin, Google Review
Amazing service, craftsmanship, design!
“Amazing service, craftsmanship, design! I ordered a custom design shower cake for my daughter’s bridal shower. The cake was by far the hit of the day. Great experience, I would highly recommend.”
Terri Sloan, Google Review
5. Serano Bakery
Serano Bakery is run by brothers Christos and Kostas Takas, who began their careers in Greece, mastering traditional baking and pastry techniques. With over 30 years of combined experience, they brought their skills to Canada.
You can start by choosing your sponge (chocolate or vanilla) and filling—options range from chocolate, vanilla, caramel, and mocha to Greek tiramisu, black forest, and mango.
Frosting type, trim color, cake message, and writing color can all be added and customized, too. Then, you can finish it off with unique extras like fresh strawberry decor, cream flowers, or edible pearls for that extra pizzazz.
Despite these awesome customization options, not everything’s perfect. We heard about cakes arriving in the wrong colors, so you might want to be very clear (and firm) with your instructions.
One of the best bakeries in the GTA
“Can we take time to appreciate this beautiful family-owned bakery, which, in my opinion, is one of the best bakeries in the GTA. What I love the most about this bakery, besides the sweets, is their customer service. Regardless of whether you come during the busiest time or their closing time, this staff’s energy and patience are unmatched; they have a smile on their faces while they serve you, and they are easy to approach if you have questions. Please do visit if you’re in GTA and thank me later…. 🙏🏽”
Fawsiyo Cosoble, Google Review
Buttercreams & fillings used have all been delicious
“Came here on a bakery tour and got a selection of cake slices. (Oreo, Tiramisu, Caramel & Mocha). All the slices have been delicious. The cake is so light and airy, and the buttercreams and fillings used have all been delicious. It’s crazy that such quality slices of cake are being sold at such an affordable price. I will definitely be back again to try more.”
Joshua Mitchell, Google Review
